Claim Information
In keeping with our office motto and offering service 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year, following is a comprehensive listing of phone numbers to file a claim directly with our companies. In order to expedite the claim filing process, please review the list below and contact your company directly. A Notice of Claim will immediately be provided directly to our office.
If you should have any problems filing your claim or need assistance, please call our office at 1-877-243-0260 or 585-243-0260.
| COMPANY |
CLAIM PHONE NUMBER |
| Allegany Co-Op |
800-333-1679 |
| Andover |
800-225-0770 |
| Chautauqua Patrons |
Business Hours: 800-896-4720
After Hours: 716-640-0126 |
| Countryway (Commercial) |
Business Hours: 877-367-6570
After Hours: 888-223-3649 |
| Countryway (Personal) |
Business Hours: 800-828-6862
After Hours: 888-223-3649 |
| Dryden Mutual Insurance |
800-782-0154 |
| Erie & Niagara Insurance |
800-234-9876 |
| National General |
800-325-1088 |
| Hagerty |
800-747-5348 |
| Hartford |
800-327-3636 |
| LoVullo |
800-876-3065 or 716-856-3065 |
| Main Street America (Personal Insurance) |
877-425-2467
Glass Claims Only: 800-887-5944 |
| National Grange Mutual (Commerical Insurance) |
800-962-5515 or 877-425-5467 |
| Merchants Insurance |
800-952-5246 |
| NYCM and A Central |
888-234-6926 |
| North Country Insurance |
800-847-7030 |
| Preferred Mutual Insurance |
800-333-7642 |
| Progressive |
877-776-4737
Glass Claims Only: 800-287-5078 |
| Travelers (Personal) |
800-238-6225 |
| Travelers (Flood) |
800-356-6670 |
| Utica National Insurance |
800-216-1420 |
|